That one there

That one there has a cold

That one there is crying.

That one there is old…

…and dying

That one there has cancer

That one there needs surgery

That one there was a dancer…

…but after the stoke she can only count to three

That one there is infected

That one there is in pain

That one there is addicted..

…to cocaine

That one there can’t see

That one there can’t hear

That one there is me

That one there is someone dear

 

Advertisements

I’m not grumpy, I’m just detoxing from caffeine!

Every once in a while, I look at my desk and notice 1…2…3…6… mugs: empty, forlorn and frankly scary. I drink a lot of coffee. I’m aware of it. I console my self thinking that everyone has one vice, right? Mine is caffeine! It’s a legal drug, it’s all good. But my caffeine habit creeps up on me and suddenly I need a coffee to get me through the next hour. Every once in a while I decide to detox. Go cold Turkey… Continue reading

BMI – Are we hiding our fat behind the facts?

Disclaimer: I am not a health care professional (yet :D) and therefore I do not claim that everything written below is completely accurate. I have endeavoured to be as accurate as possible and have indicated which are my own speculations and opinions. However, if you wish to make changes to your lifestyle, I would urge you to speak with a qualified health care professional and only use the below information as a guide. 

My story:

Back in April 2015, I made a decision to become healthy and loose weight. I even blogged about my journey. It was very optimistic. I lost a lot of weight in the first 6 months. 15 kilograms, to be exact. My blood pressure returned to normal. (For every kilogram of weight loss, your systolic blood pressure decreases by 2 points. Diastolic is a similar story.) I was able to run up and down the stairs without getting out of breath. I could fit into my old clothes again. In short, whatever trial and error process I did, it worked…

…for a while.

Now, I am 13 months on from my original start point. And overall I have lost 17 kilograms. Which means that in the last 7 months I’ve lost only 2 kilograms. I didn’t get it. I could see my stomach going in, my waist line reducing, my face getting more structure and yet the scales told a different story. Having despite put in more exercise and improving my eating habits even further, my weight remained stubbornly the same. I started going to the gym even harder. I changed up my exercise regime, I listened to my body – I took care. I could see the benefits really clearly. I went up from 2kg weight to 3…to 4…to 5…and I no longer needed to make two trips to the car because I could carry all the shopping in one go. I could complete my mile walks in less time. I felt physically the most fit I have ever felt. And yet my weight did not budge. And as a result, I have been stuck in the same BMI category of ‘overweight’ for the past 7 months. Something was definitely messed up. How could I be literally ‘shrinking’ in terms of fitting into clothes and yet weigh exactly the same as before? It took me ages to work it out and I think I have. But we’ll come back to me in just a moment.

Body Mass Index (BMI)

Body Mass Index (BMI) is the most commonly used screening tool for obesity. Intended for use in adults (there is a separate measure for children and toddlers) , it is a fairly straightforward concept. All is required is the weight (in kg) and height (in metres) of the individual. Then you divide the weight in kg by the height in metres (squared).

So if Bob is a 1.86m tall man who weight 95 kilograms, his BMI will be:

  • Weight in kg : 95
  • Divided by height in metres squared : 95 / 1.86^2
  • BMI = 27.5

Below are the BMI ranges:

  • Underweight:  > 18.5 and below
  • Normal: 18.5  –  24.9
  • Overweight: 25-29.9
  • Obese: 30 – 34.9
  • Morbidly obese : 35 +

This puts Bob in the overweight category. He should probably loose some weight so that his chances of diabetes Type 2, stroke, heart attack, high blood pressure and other nasty diseases all decrease.

But let me give you some more information on Bob.

  • He is a full-time builder
  • He is also member of his local rugby team and takes part in matches every weekend
  • For this reason he works out at the gym a lot so that he can develop his muscles

Would you still say that Bob is overweight? To be honest, yes, he could very well still be overweight, we haven’t actually met Bob (and he’s made up) but the more likely answer is that actually the extra weight Bob is carrying isn’t from extra fat but actually from extra muscle!

Lets now talk about Bob’s wife, Samantha.

Samantha is a professional long distance runner. She is 1.54 m and weighs 45kg. This puts her BMI at 18.9. She is at the very low end of normal weight, but should she put on more weight? Not necessarily. Being a long distance runner means that she probably has a lot of lean muscle (Slow twitch, Type 1 muscle). Whereas Bob needs a lot of strength to be a builder and play rugby (lots of fast-twitch, Type 2 muscle AND slow twitch Type 1 muscle) While Bob requires his muscles to be powerful and strong, Samantha needs her muscles to not fatigue easily. She requires endurance muscle.

And now back to me…

Recently, I had my full body analysed and measured for body fat percentage, total body weight and given ranges for what percentage my fat should fall into. (This was all done at university as part of our teaching on exercise physiology) For my height and weight, it was recommended that I be between 21 – 33% fat from total body weight.

  • My total % of body fat was 25% : well within (if not towards the lower end) of the range
  • My BMI: 29.

Do you see my conundrum? How can I be on one hand a BMI of 29, which puts me in the overweight category and simultaneously have a low-normal body fat percentage?

One answer would be that I’m like Bob. But I’m not a builder, I don’t need to have powerful muscles and of course, I do not. So it can’t be big muscle that is weighing me down.

Another answer could be that I’m a little like Samantha. My muscles might not be big in size (hypertrophy) but the lean endurance muscles might have developed. The only issue with this theory is that Type 1 endurance muscle (the kind that Samantha has more of) doesn’t really cause an increase in weight. So it is unlikely that I was developing only this type of muscle. Otherwise, weight should have decreased as the fat burned.

A few people (both professional and non-professional) speculated that perhaps it was the bones themselves that were adding to weight! And Rightly so, bones between individuals can vary in density. It follows therefore that people with denser bone will weigh more.

My verdict: it is probably a combination of all the above. It is true that I have been doing much more endurance exercise (apart from when I lifted too quickly and damaged my wrist). Consequently I must have been burning fat at the same time as developing endurance muscle (and to some extent strength muscles). Overall, causing my weight to remain the same but on the insides the composition of fat and muscle has changed.

Final thoughts:

BMI is a screening tool. By definition it means that it is not a diagnostic tool. It won’t definitely tell us if an individual is obese or not but it can give an indication whether a person is likely to be obese or not. I think using BMI in isolation is a mistake and possibly a bit misleading. It should be, in my opinion, used alongside the personal circumstances and fitness history of an individual. BMI should also be used alongside other screening tools like the full body fat analyser and waist: hip ratios.

Furthermore: somebody with a normal BMI, normal fitness can still be carrying a lot of visceral fat. This is fat around the organs and is just as dangerous as having visible fat. A lot of it is common sense too. If you’re doing no physical activity at all and eating take aways every day, likelihood is that your fat percentage (and probably BMI) are both going to be high.

I’m not entirely sure what to make of my results now. I think I’ll probably carry on the way I’ve been going. I still have a personal goal to meet. But in the mean time, at least I know that my body fat is very much in the normal range!

Thank you for reading. If you have any thoughts, please comment below!

-Vitzy-

EDIT: 11 hours after this post was initially published, I received a very helpful comment and have taken the errors pointed out and edited them. The only difference between this edited version and the previous version is that Samantha is now a long distance runner rather than a dancer. If you notice any errors or would like to give any other suggestions, please comment below.

“You have hair on your chin…”

A couple of months before my 15th birthday, my mum took me into the doctor’s surgery. The following weeks revolved around concerned parents, blood tests, lots of doctors including paediatricians, gynaecologists, endocrinologists and even radiologists and finally a diagnosis of PCOS.

PCOS, short for Polycystic Ovarian Syndrome, is an endocrinological disorder which affects the hormones oestrogen and testosterone. It results in multiple small follicles (eggs) in the ovaries which struggle to mature. The main result of this is irregular periods. The high testosterone results in male pattern hair growth and skin problems.  Continue reading

Suicide – it is not always obvious

Somebody I once knew very well committed suicide last week. I don’t know if I should be feeling a certain emotion. Should I be sad? Angry at the world for betraying her? Should I be frustrated that these things happen and we can’t prevent them? At first, to be honest, I was shocked. And slightly unbelieving. You see this person was the happiest, smiling and bubbly people you’d meet. At least that was what it looked like from the outside. I suppose she only really let us see this side of her and who knows what demons were running rampant inside her mind and body. Continue reading

Plodding along

  1. Medical school
  2. Weight loss
  3. Mental Health
  4. Writings
  5. Professional and personal relationships

These things take time. They develop and improve over years, sometimes, not just days. There’ll be good days, bad days and just plain terrible days. If you too have a similar list as mine and have a million and one things that just don’t seem to end, know that you’re certainly not alone and are working towards a massive but by no means an unachievable goal.

Also, if you have to focus on something, make that focus your own health. None of the other things will be worth it if you’re not well enough to enjoy them!

Peace for now

-Vitzy-